Franz Joseph Haydn

From CCARH Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Franz Josef Haydn was one of the best-loved composers of the eighteenth century. His string quartets, symphonies, concertos, masses, keyboard, and chamber music all became models of their genres. Haydn encapsulated the eighteenth-century ideal of well articulated organization, balance of resources with enough rotation to avoid blandness, and a critical ear. The music was famously good-natured and found an easy reception.

Yet Haydn himself never received the praise for his operas he would have wished. Many were written for performance in Eisenstadt, where his employer's wife was an Italian noblewoman with a significant interest in the genre. Ironically, Haydn's operas are more approachable today than they were in his time. Some, on texts by Carlo Goldoni, are comic. Many contain a pleasant balance between vocal and instrumental pieces, for Haydn was even-handed in his approach to all kinds of music.


String quartet prints of Haydn's Time

No complete edition of all of Haydn's works was organized until a few decades ago. In the absence of a comprehensive critical edition, Haydn's music has been circulated in a great bevy of short runs from his time to our own. CCARH had the good fortune to acquire bits and pieces of several string-quartet editions from Haydn's lifetime. The concurrent series testify to the popularity of the repertory in general but also to its proliferation in France and England.

Music publishers of Haydn's time

Robert Bremner (c1713-1789) was a publisher of music in Edinburgh. His main interest was in bringing out primers on how to play specific instruments and mastering techniques such as vibrato.These were occasionally issued together with new issues of string quartets. The collection of plates and copyrights he acquired over his lifetime became an enviable one.

Ignace Joseph Pleyel (1757-1831) was born near Vienna with the name Ignaz Pleyl. Naturalized in France, he pursued a musical education, studying from the age of twelve with Jean-Baptiste Vanhal (1739-1815), then securing support from the count Ladislaus Erdödy to study with Haydn as Eisenstadt. In 1777 Pleyel was named director of music at the court of his benefactor and, soon after, director of the orchestra of Prince Esterhazy at Eisenstadt. Pleyel's first string quartet appeared in 1782, but two years later he was appointed director of music at the Strasbourg Cathedral. Rising revolutionary sentiments in France in 1791 forced him to go to London, where he joined Haydn in the Salomon concerts. Upon his return to Frence Pleyel was stripped of his position in Strasbourg. Les éditions de la Maison Pleyel began to appear in 1797. They published more than 4,000 chamber works in slightly less than 40 years. In 1802 the Maison published a complete edition of Haydn string quartets in performing parts. Dedicated to Napoleon Bonaparte, it is fully reproduced here. In 1807 the first Pleyel pianos began to appear. Ultimately popularity of Pleyel pianos eclipsed the importance of its prints. The small score edition of the quartets Haydn's popular "Op. 20" reproduced here must come from the period 1815-1830.

Charles Simon Richault (1780-1866) of Chartres became an apprentice in music printing to Jérome-Joseph de Momigny (1762-1842), whose primary interest was in formal theories of music. Richault's independent activity as a music publisher started in 1805. After Pleyel's death in 1834, several publishers bid on various components of his recently compiled catalog of several thousand works. The Richault works linked here were among those that came from the Pleyel 1834 catalog. The Richault firm became much better known in later decades later, when it was operated by his grandson Léon. Under his management Les édition Richault became known for first editions of Berlioz, the first French editions of Bach and Handel oratorios, and the more standard repertories of Beethoven symphonies and Mozart concertos.

The T. Trautwein firm operated as a book and music distributor in Berlin from 1829 until the firm was taken over in 1890. Its music offerings included dances, songs, piano, and chamber music. Haydn's quartets may have been the earliest repertory in its catalog. Among the publishers listed here it was the most recent in origin. What it gained from that position was a consistency that is sometimes lacking in earlier exemplars. The quartets reproduced here appeared in 1840 and were identified inside each print as coming from a "Leipzig cahier".

Haydn quartets: Table of reproductions from early prints

Hoboken Title Bremner Trautwein Pleyel Richault RISM A/I Work “Opus” Comment

III:1 Divertimento Op. 1. N.1 H 3437 1 1/1 “The Hunt”
III:2 Divertimento Op. 1, N.2 H 3437 2 1/2
III:3 Divertimento Op. 1, N.3 H 3437 3 1/3
III:4 Divertimento Op. 1, N.4 H 3437 4 1/4
III:5 Divertimento Op. 1, N.5 H 3437 5 1/5 spurious
III:6 Divertimento Op. 1, N.6 H 3437 6 1/6
III:7 Divertimento 7 2/1 no copy
III:8 Divertimento 8 2/2 no copy
III:9 Divertimento 2/3 spurious
III:10 Divertimento 9 2/4 no copy
III:11 Divertimento 2/5 spurious
III:12 Divertimento 10 2/6 no copy
III:13 String quartet 3/1 spurious
III:14 String quartet 3/2 spurious
III:15 String quartet 3/3 spurious
III:16 String quartet 3/4 spurious
III:17 String quartet 3/5 spurious
III:18 String quartet 3/6 spurious
III:19 Divertimento 12 9/1 no copy
III:20 Divertimento 704 14 9/2
III:21 Divertimento 800 13 9/3
III:22 Divertimento 11 9/4 no copy
III:23 Divertimento 15 9/5 no copy
III:24 Divertimento 16 9/6 no copy
III:25 Divertimento 705 18 17/1
III:26 Divertimento 724 17 17/2
III:27 Divertimento 777 21 17/3
III:28 Divertimento 19 17/4 no copy
III:29 Divertimento 811 22 17/5
III:30 Divertimento 834 20 17/6
III:31 Divertimento 752 28 20/1
III:32 Divertimento 799 25 20/2
III:33 Divertimento 26 20/3 no copy
III:34 String quartet 815 IV/2 H 3363 27 20/4
III:35 String quartet 698 IV/1 H 3363 23 20/5
III:36 String quartet IV/3 H 3363 24 20/6
III:37 String quartet 761 VII/1 H 3364 31 33/1
III:38 String quartet 699 VII/2 H 3364 30 33/2
III:39 String quartet VII/3 H 3364 32 33/3
III:40 String quartet 812 VIII/1 H 3364 34 33/4
III:41 String quartet 700 VIII/2 H 3364 29 33/5
III:42 String quartet VIII/3 H 3364 33 33/6
III:43 String quartet 835 35 42
III:44 String quartet VI/3 H 3366 36 50/1
III:45 String quartet 805 VI/2 H 3366 37 50/2
III:46 String quartet 759 VI/3 H 3366 38 50/3
III:47 String quartet 706 VI/2 H 3366 39 50/4
III:48 String quartet 781 V/1 H 3366 40 50/5
III:49 String quartet 810 VI/1 H 3366 41 50/6
III:50 Arr. of Sieben Worte
III:51 Arr. of Sieben Worte
III:52 Arr. of Sieben Worte
III:53 Arr. of Sieben Worte
III:54 Arr. of Sieben Worte
III:55 Arr. of Sieben Worte
III:56 Arr. of Sieben Worte
III:57 String quartet 771 42 54/2 no copy
III:58 String quartet 735 43 54/1
III:59 String quartet 814 44 54/3
III:60 String quartet 779 45 55/1
III:61 String quartet 46 55/2 no copy
III:62 String quartet 803 47 55/3
III:63 String quartet 697 53 64/5
III:64 String quartet 784 52 64/6
III:65 String quartet 783 48 64/1
III:66 String quartet 746 51 64/4
III:67 String quartet 798 50 64/3
III:68 String quartet 760 49 64/2
III:69 String quartet 711 IX/1 H 3372 54 71/1
III:70 String quartet 749 IX/2 H 3372 55 71/2
III:71 String quartet 782 IX/3 H 3372 56 71/3
III:72 String quartet 745 X/1 57 74/1
III:73 String quartet 709 X/2 58 74/2
III:74 String quartet 785 X/3 59 74/3
III:75 String quartet 751 I/1 60 76/1
III:76 String quartet 808 I/2 61 76/2
III:77 String quartet 695 I/3 62 76/3
III:78 String quartet 754 II/1 63 76/4
III:79 String quartet 707 II/2 64 76/5
III:80 String quartet 801 II/3 65 76/6
III:81 String quartet 703 66 77/1
III:82 String quartet 727 67 77/2
III:83 String quartet 68 103 unfinished

The identification of works in these scans requires consultation of the finding chart linked above. The lack of a comprehensive edition parallels the absence of a comprehensive catalog of Haydn's music, although this need was substantially met in time by the catalog of Anthony van Hoboken.

Musicians who leaf through the Haydn quartet scans rapidly develop insights in the condition of music circulation in Haydn's time. It is immediately noticeable that during the intervening two centuries many conventions of notation, particularly regardings turns and grace notes, have changed.

A much larger proportion of melodic notes were conveyed through grace notes than would be the case today. (George Barth's 1991 article on Mozart performance gives some sense of this situation.) The technically astute will find, if they investigate our encoded score data, these editions do not serve modern editors at all well. Beat-regularization squeezes many of those same small notes out of the file, which regulates musical flow by bar structure, and extensive annotation is needed to convey the composer's intentions.

Piano sonatas printed in c1900

Chamber music: Digitized sources

A recent online exhibit of Haydn resources at Stanford University provides a useful overview of the varied genres in which the composer worked. Some of the fragmentation in Haydn's oeuvre owed to the vicissitudes of patronage. Only recently a composer might have been supported throughout his life by a duke or prince. Haydn's fortunes were mixed. A great deal of his music is associated with the Esterhazy family, who had one court in Eisenstadt (on the Austrian side of today's border with Hungary) and another, grander one, some miles east of the border. Like most Austro-Hungarian, Bohemian, and Moravian nobles of the time, the Esterhazy princes also had a town house in Vienna. Chamber music found a place both in habitual locales and in Vienna.

String quartets

Haydn contributed generously to the chamber music repertory. He is most strongly associated today with the string quartet, a genre in which he coached followers including Mozart and Beethoven. The quartet genre was not so distinct then from closely associated string works, such as the divertimento and the sinfonia concertante, as it later became.

CCARH conducted experiments in encoding from early editions in the 1990s. The Haydn quartet repertory offered a particularly thorny array of available materials with no coordination between them. We offer facsimiles of the editions and some encodes files without any warranty. The notational style of early editions is often ill-suited to encoding. The variability between publishers was considerable. Current users would want to re-edit the data before using it. Yet for those studying the difficulties of the task, we have posted these materials without any restrictions on their use.

Catalog numeration systems

Three systems of numeration for Haydn quartets are in common use. One enumerates single works, one enumerates collections of works by “opus number,” and one (“Hoboken”) assigns an arbitrary number to single works for bibliographical reference. This listing is ordered by the first, with cross-references to the other two. In efforts to encode the early prints, we encountered basic problems of reference: Which exact work was under discussion? This led is to create a table to coordinate all the materials. It is instructive in clarifying the scope of the problem. <Add table>

A Hoboken catalog designation contains a Roman numeral prefix (III=the string quartet category) and an Arabic numeral indicating the approximate order in which the work was composed (or assumed to be composed), e.g. III:10. (Some numbered works are now known to be spurious and should be excluded from analytical applications.)

Early and recent editions of Haydn string quartets

Most Haydn quartets in the MuseData database come from early nineteenth-century editions, especially those by Trautwein, Pleyel, and Bremmer. Most Haydn quartets were published in small groups of works, so one print number may pertain to several works.

Quartet numbers which are commonly used in modern performing editions and recordings reflect the arbitrary assignment of opus numbers as used by more recent publishers. Each publisher had his own self-referential system of identifying new titles. As many of six or several instances of a fictitious String Quartet Op. 1 could prove to be musically independent works.

When quartets were published in sets, the order of works within the set was determined by the publisher. It did not necessarily duplicate the order used by another publisher. The order in which the works were arranged varied from one collection to the next. Not all works were called “string quartets” on their first appearance. Widely circulated editions of the past half-century employ their own naming and numbering systems.

Symphonic editions (CCARH)

Unlike other major composers of his generation, Haydn was not honored with a catalogue or a complete edition of works in the nineteenth century. The reasons for this are many and varied. Haydn's chamber music was printed in short editions by scattered publishers, each with a different system for numbering both works and editions. The Hoboken catalogue does its job well but it often difficult to link up with random editions. (See further remarks under String Quartets. Comprehensive Haydn symphony lists appear in the Hoboken Thematic Catalogue.

The London Symphonies

By 1790, Haydn had spent three decades in the employ of the Esterhazy princes. The death of Prince Nicholas led inadvertently the dismissal of the court orchestra. A new offer of patronage from the German impresario J. P. Salomon enabled Haydn to hear his music played by an orchestra of substantial size in London. Haydn's music was already well known and frequently heard there. An added benefit to Haydn was the local publishers were eager to bring out the latest works and to license further editions on the Continent. He ultimately prepared to two sets of six symphonies, one set performed in 1791-92 and the other in 1794-95. Apart from their great success in London, many of these works have remained favorites every since.

Our selection of encoded symphonies emphasizes the later works that show off his talents to best advantage. Users will find that each one is different from the others but fully transparent.

Symphony No. (Date) Hoboken No. Genre / Instruments Key Nickname Score
No. 93 (1791) I:093 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb D Major Full score
No. 94 (1791) I:094 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb G Major "The Surprise" Full score
No. 95 (1791) I:095 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb C Minor Full score
No. 96 (1791) I:096 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb D Major "The Miracle" Full score
No. 97 (1791-92) I:097 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb C Major Full score
No. 98 (1791-92) I:098 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb B Major Full score
No. 99 (1793) I:099 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Cl/B, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb E Major Full score
No. 100 (1793-94) I:100 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb G Major "The Military" Full score
No. 101 (1793-94) I:101 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Cl/A, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb D Major "The Clock" Full score
No. 102 (1794) I:102 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb B Major Full score
No. 103 (1795) I:103 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Cl/B 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb E Major "The Drumroll" Full score
No. 104 (1795) I:104 Symphony / 2Fl, 2Ob, 2Cl/A, 2Bn; 2Hrn/D, 2Tr/D, Tmp; 2V, Va, Vc, Cb D Major "London" Full score


  • George Barth, "Mozart performance in the nineteenth-century," Early Music, 19/4 (Nov. 1991), 538-552.
  • Rita Benton, "Pleyel as a music publisher," Journal of the American Musicological Society, 32/1 (1979), 125-140.